Understanding the National Debt: Uncle Sam’s Borrowing Habit

Imagine running your household. You earn money (income), spend on essentials (expenses), and sometimes need to borrow for bigger purchases (debt) that exceed your income or savings. The national debt is similar, but on a much larger scale, affecting the entire country. While it is not the same as the US has some other unique features that allow it to potentially borrow more, it acts in the same way.

What is it?

The National Debt is simply the total amount of money the US government owes. It accumulates whenever the government spends more than it collects in taxes and other revenue. It is like using a credit card – convenient in the short term, but the bill comes due eventually and like a credit card the Government must pay interest on the debt in the form of Interest payments, often referred to as Debt service.

Who manages it?

Several key players manage the National Debt:

  • The Treasury Department1: They issue debt instruments like Treasury bills, notes, and bonds, borrowing money from investors to raise money “credit” for the Government.
  • The Federal Reserve: They play a role in managing interest rates, which affect the cost of borrowing for the government. They set a key borrowing rate known as the Fed Funds rate at which other banks’ rates are set against. As interest rates rise, so does the expense of service the debt, much like credit card companies raising the interest rates for your credit.
  • Congress: They authorize the government to spend and borrow money, responsible for managing the debt. Congress holds the purse strings on spending by authorizing spending bills and setting the Debt limit with authorized Debt ceilings.

Who does what?

Several independent agencies track the National Debt:

  • Government Accountability Office (GAO): They audit the government’s financial statements and report on the debt.
  • Congressional Budget Office (CBO): They provide economic forecasts and analyze the impact of debt on the budget.
  • Bureau of the Fiscal Service: They manage the day-to-day operations of the national debt.
  • Executive (President of the United States): The President sets the Fiscal Policy, Priorities, and Plan for the budget. 
  • Office of Management and Budget (OMB): They help prepare the President’s budget, manage the Execution once Congress has approved the budget, and manage the oversight and performance management of the budget.

How does it grow or shrink?

Debt grows when the government spends more than it takes in. This can happen through various scenarios:

  • Fiscal Policy: When the President’s Fiscal Policy spends (intentionally or unintentionally) more than the taxes and revenue collected.
  • Tax cuts: When taxes are lowered and not offset by the Economic growth from the tax cuts.
  • Increased spending: More money on programs like entitlements including Social Security and Medicare or discretionary items like national defense, infrastructure programs add to the debt.
  • Economic downturns: When the economy shrinks, tax revenue falls, and the government chooses to borrow to stimulate it instead of reducing spending.
  • Exogenous events: Events like the 2008 Financial Crisis, Wars, or the COVID Pandemic can lead to debt spending to address.

The debt shrinks when the government collects more revenue than it spends or through strategic debt payments. Many of these are possible but often not used as they can be politically risky.

  • Government Spending Cuts: The Government can reduce spending by cutting or reducing programs.
  • Increased Taxes: The Government can increase taxes, although the long-term effects are mixed potentially reducing long-term growth which also impacts taxes collected. 
  • Economic Growth: While not shrinking the debt, as the Economy grows more taxes are collected. If expenses remain the same, growth will reduce the ratio of expenses to revenue, effectively shrinking the budget.

Where does it fit in with spending and policy?

Fiscal policy is set by the President and refers to how the government manages its spending and taxes. It is a balancing act: providing essential services while keeping the debt under control. Like household credit it must be balanced with the benefits of immediate spending versus the challenges of paying items back later knowing that for every dollar you put on credit you will be reducing your available money to spend because a portion of your income will now go to credit card fees.

“If you choose not to decide, you still have made a choice”

Freewill performed by Rush

Historical context

The National Debt started during the Revolutionary War to finance the fight for US Independence. Since then, it has fluctuated based on several factors like wars, economic recessions, and government priorities.

How is it authorized?

Congress authorizes the government to borrow money by passing legislation, setting limits on the amount of debt allowed, known as the Debt Ceiling. From time to time this limit must be authorized to expand the Debt Ceiling to enable more debt to pay government bills. 

The Future?

The National Debt is a complex issue with no easy solutions. Balancing competing priorities, managing interest payments, and ensuring long-term economic stability are key challenges. While there is no magic bullet, responsible fiscal policy, public understanding, and informed debate are crucial for navigating the complexities of the National Debt. The debt burden and interest on the National Debt are very real and left unmanaged can lead to negative consequences to the Economy and our Country. 

Understanding the National Debt: Uncle Sam’s Borrowing Habit

Tightrope Walk: Navigating the US Economy and Rising National Debt

The US Economy, measured by its Gross Domestic Product (GDP), represents the total value of all goods and services produced within a year. However, looming over this economic output is the ever-growing shadow of National Debt, raising concerns about sustainability and future generations. This article delves into the comparison between these two figures, explores how recent events impacted them, and examines the challenges posed by a large National Debt exceeding the size of the US Economy.

The National Debt of the United States has been steadily climbing, driven by several factors including fiscal policy, increased spending, and economic downturns. The COVID pandemic significantly accelerated this trend, adding over $7 trillion to the debt, while the roots run deeper. The Great Recession of 2008 also played a major role, pushing the debt-to-GDP ratio above 60% for the first time since World War II. As of Valentines Day 2024, the US National Debt stands at a staggering $34.3 trillion, that’s 34 x 10(12), exceeding 125% of the country’s GDP1.

Inflationary Dance with Debt

This high debt burden intersects with another economic concern: inflation. Increased spending and money supply expansion are often cited as contributing factors to inflation. In 2023, the US experienced inflation rates not seen in decades, exceeding 9% at one point2. While complex and multifaceted, the correlation between debt, money supply, and inflation cannot be ignored3. As Warren Buffett famously said, “Only when the tide goes out do you discover who’s been swimming naked.” Growth in money supply does not automatically mean inflation, but if it outpaces productivity, inflation often follows.

“Only when the tide goes out do you discover who’s been swimming naked.” 4

Warren Buffet

Sustainability Concerns and Interest Bite

Beyond inflation, a ballooning debt raises concerns about its long-term impact. Servicing the debt consumes an increasingly larger portion of the federal budget, diverting resources from crucial areas. The interest on our debt in 2023 reached $659 billion dollars4, to put that in perspective there are less than 40 countries in the World whose entire economy is greater than the interest alone we are paying on our debt5. As interest rates rise, often seen during periods when the Federal Reserve is combatting inflation, interest payments balloon exacerbating the challenge of pay down the debt. Additionally, a high debt can weaken investor confidence, potentially leading to higher borrowing costs and hampering economic growth6.7

“I have yet to see a time when it made sense to bet against America. And I doubt very much that any reader of this letter will have a different experience in the future.”

Warren Buffett

Balancing Act and Looking Ahead

Managing the national debt requires a delicate balancing act. Reducing spending can be politically unpopular, and raising taxes carries economic risks. Meanwhile, relying solely on economic growth for debt reduction is an uncertain strategy. Finding a sustainable path forward necessitates responsible fiscal policy (spending within our means) and bipartisan cooperation, both of which remain elusive in the current political climate.

However, as Warren Buffett has bullishly stated: “I have yet to see a time when it made sense to bet against America. And I doubt very much that any reader of this letter will have a different experience in the future.”

While expressing confidence in the long-term potential of the US economy, acknowledging the need for responsible debt management remains crucial.

Tightrope Walk: Navigating the US Economy and Rising National Debt

Tax Project Institute

Get the Newsletter

Sign up to get the newsletter